| Year | MEN | WOMEN |
| 1983 | John Bauman | Kelly Elliot |
| 1984 | Mark Mizuba | Kelly Elliot |
| 1985 | John Johannes | Kelly Elliot |
| 1986 | Dave Utley | Jane Hilarzewski |
| 1987 | Dave Utley | Gretchen Jensen |
| 1988 | William Morosky | Christel Smith |
| 1989 | Robert North | Gretchen Jensen |
| 1990 | Paul Dawson | Kelly Knaus |
| 1991 | Paul Dawson | Kelly Knaus |
| 1992 | William Morosky | Kelly Knaus |
| 1993 | William Morosky | Kelly Knaus |
| 1994 | Randy Charcalla | Jane Hilarzewski |
| 1995 | Randy Charcalla | Kelly Knaus |
| 1996 | Randy Charcalla | Jane Hilarzewski |
| 1997 | Jason Charcalla | Jane Hilarzewski |
| 1998 | George Drushel | Jane Hilarzewski |
| 1999 | Rick Podbielski | Laura Brockenbraugh |
| 2000 | ChadWeaver | Nancy Herbst |
| 2001 | George Drushel | Laura Brockenbraugh |
| 2002 | Adam Holland | Jen Slack |
| 2003 | Kevin Louis | Jen Slack |
| 2004 | Adam Holland | Kristen Curtze |
| 2005 | Bill Bauman | Melanie Reade |
| 2006 | Dan Pierce | Melanie Reade |
| 2007 | Jared Heine | Melanie Reade |
| 2008 | Jared Heine | Tara Quinn |
| 2009 | Jared Heine | Melanie Reade |
| 2010 | Jared Heine | Nicolina Pierce |
| 2011 | Kelsey Ferrante | Jared Heine |
Kelly Latimer of the YMCA of Greater Erie • klatimer@ymcaerie.org.
All photos, unless otherwise noted, by Mark Bowen Studio
